A family at Sandy Lake

My family’s Ojibwe ancestry has been traced back to a woman named Margaret or Ma Chay, who was born around 1800 at Sandy Lake, which was a major Ojibwe village located in what is now northeast Minnesota in the 18th and early 19th century.   According to Anton Treuer’s book The Assassination of Hole in the Day, Hole in the Day the Elder was a prominent chief at Sandy Lake and his son Hole in the Day the Younger was born there.

Sandy Lake was also the site of important trading posts during the fur trade era.  In 1794 the Northwest Company established a post on the west shore of the lake that remained in operation until after the War of 1812.  A law passed in 1816 required all trading with Indians be conducted by American citizens, which forced the Northwest Company to sell its holdings in the U.S. to John Jacob Astor. Astor’s American Fur Company operated the old fort for several years before establishing a new fort on the Sandy River, which connects Sandy Lake to the Mississippi. Several other independent trading houses also may have existed in the area.

The trading posts are important to our family’s story because it is likely that Margaret met Alexander Blair at one these posts. According to government records, Blair is listed as the father of Margaret’s four children: Angeline (born 1819), Antoine (1827?), Edward (1829?) and Alex (1840?).  Given the time span between the oldest and youngest, it appears that Margaret and Alexander had a long-term relationship.

Unfortunately, I have found no solid information for Alexander beyond his name.  Having read as much as I can about the fur trade in the early 19th century, including employee lists of the trading companies, I have yet to find any mention of him. I have found other potential clues. There was an Alexander Blair who served in Canada in the British army during the War of 1812. Is it possible that our Alexander stayed behind after the war? There are also a couple of Alexander Blairs who show up in city directories for Detroit and other cities in Michigan and upstate New York in the 1840s and 1850s.  Was our Alexander one of many white men who, after making their fortune in the fur trade, abandoned their native families and returned to “civilization” to start another life? It is unlikely that I will find any connections between these men and our family, but I’ll keep looking.

Unfortunately, there is also little information about Margaret.  Her name shows up in the “Half-Breed Scrip” report, which investigated the use of scrip to issue land claims under the 1854 Treaty. The investigating commission had as one of their sources a trader named Peter Roy, who claimed to know Margaret. Roy stated that she and her three children who filed claims for scrip in 1864 were from Sandy Lake and were mixed blood Ojibwe of Lake Superior.  The commission ruled that Margaret was not eligible for scrip because Margaret was married before 1854, and therefore was not a head of household when the treaty was signed. Apparently, because Margaret was ineligible for scrip, the claims of her children were also rejected. Census records indicate that Margaret lived with one of her sons through at least 1870 and the sons and her daughter all settled together at Little Rock Lake north of present-day Sauk Rapids (the next part of the story will be in a future post).

My sense is that Alexander Blair died at Sandy Lake. I have no way of verifying this, of course. The burial grounds at Sandy Lake have long since been covered up by lake homes and condos.  Or was he buried along side a trail or portage somewhere? Did he drown? There are many possibilities, all of which suggest Alexander Blair was one of many men involved in the fur trade who are lost to history.

9 thoughts on “A family at Sandy Lake

  1. Have you thought of getting your DNA tested? I also have many unknowns in my ancestry. My native family looks more like swiss cheese due to all the gaps. I had my DNA tested last year through 23andMe, and picked up several dozen previously unknown native American relatives ranging from coast to coast. Unfortunately none had new information that would fill in my gaps. I also transferred my DNA results to gedmatch.com, working one afternoon last summer with another native genealogy researcher – and suddenly discovered I was something like a 3rd cousiin to her late husband, a big surprise to both of us. We still don’t know the exact details, though.


      • No big difference. When you get your results from AncestryDNA, go to a website gedmatch.com and sign up with them. They have a way of transferring your data from Ancestry into their files – which are then matched to my files which I uploaded to gedmatch last summer, along with everyone else in the world who has done the same. When I got to gedmatch I found several thousand matches I didn’t know about through 23andMe. Some of the gedmatches belong to the same tribe I belong to, Grand Traverse Band of Ottawa & Chippewa Indians, although I have not yet been able to document just how this happened. Almost certainly your DNA results will match mine at some level on gedmatch.com, once you get around to it. My sister & niece & another cousin have also been tested on 23andMe, but they won’t go to the extent of uploading their data to gedmatch.com, all are also Trotochaud descendants. That’s very frustrating. I have another 23andMe test pending on a 1st cousin once removed, another Trotochaud descendant. Since I am managing his case, I will definitely upload his data to gedmatch.com as soon as possible, might be within a few months.
        I have been trying to contact the other MN Trotochaud descendant who actually had his Y chromosome matched to our presumed French connection, but he hasn’t answer for months now. I am checking with the French cousin to see if they can upload their data to gedmatch.


  2. It seems we share commen ancestry. Margaret just so happens to be my great great great great great grandmother. I also am struggling to find information.


  3. Hi

    i am an ancestor of Isabelle and Antoine. I remember my Uncle indicating that Balir came down from Canada and I seem to remember Quebec and involved in the fur trade. My mother seemed to feel we had Scottish ancestry. She did make reference as a young child tending the garden with a older relative that was bossy and the children would make fun of the language she would speak. French..Ojibwa i don’t know. Also she commented that a grandmother had nice English dishware in her attic. However with the names of the children seem to have a french origin perhaps.


    • Hi Patrick,

      The possible Scottish background is intriguing. It may be that we could find a connection through fur company records. Good to hear from you – thanks for reading!



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s